Skip to main content

LLM Thinking: Reinforcement Learning and the Emergence of Reasoning

Introduction:​

We've explored the basics of reinforcement learning (RL) in LLMs. Now, let's delve into the cutting-edge research and practical applications of RL, focusing on the DeepSeek R1 paper and the concept of "thinking models."

1. The DeepSeek R1 Breakthrough: Unlocking Reasoning​

  • The Significance:

    • The DeepSeek R1 paper from DeepSeek Kai in China publicly detailed the power of RL in LLM training.
    • It demonstrated how RL can significantly enhance LLM reasoning capabilities, particularly in complex problem-solving.
  • The Math Problem Example Revisited:​
    • The paper showed a significant improvement in LLM accuracy on math problems after RL fine-tuning.
    • This isn't just about getting the right answer; it's about how the LLM arrives at the answer.
  • Emergent Thinking:​
    • The most remarkable finding was the emergence of "thinking" in LLMs through RL.
    • LLMs began to generate longer, more detailed solutions, demonstrating a step-by-step reasoning process.
    • This includes re-evaluating steps, trying different perspectives, and backtracking, much like human problem-solving.
  • Why it's important:​
    • RL teaches the model how to think, not just to repeat solutions.
    • It is not possible to hardcode these methods into training data.
2. Thinking Models: A New Frontier​
  • Definition:​
    • "Thinking models" are LLMs trained with RL techniques that enable them to generate detailed reasoning processes.
    • They go beyond simple imitation and demonstrate genuine problem-solving strategies.
  • Accessing Thinking Models:​
    • DeepSeek R1 is available on chat.deepseek.com and together.ai.
    • OpenAI offers thinking models in its GPT-4 01 and 03 variants (available with a paid subscription).
    • Google's Gemini 2.0 Flash Thinking is also an experimental thinking model.
  • The Difference:​
    • Standard LLMs (like GPT-4) primarily rely on supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and don't exhibit the same level of detailed reasoning.
    • They are great for knowledge retrieval, but not as good at difficult problem solving.
  • Practical Applications:​
    • Thinking models are particularly useful for complex tasks requiring in-depth reasoning, such as math, coding, and logical puzzles.
  • Caveats:​
    • Thinking models often generate longer responses, which can increase processing time.
    • They are still experimental, and their performance may vary.
3. The AlphaGo Connection: RL in AI​
  • Historical Context:​
    • The discovery of RL's power in LLMs echoes the success of AlphaGo, DeepMind's AI system that mastered the game of Go.
    • AlphaGo demonstrated the ability of RL to learn complex strategies through self-play and feedback.
  • The Lesson:​
    • RL is a powerful tool for teaching AI systems to learn and adapt in complex environments.
    • The application of RL to LLMs is a natural extension of this principle.
  • What it means:​
    • RL is not new to the field of AI, and has been used to great effect in other areas.
4. The Importance of Understanding RL​
  • Beyond Imitation:
    • RL allows LLMs to go beyond simple imitation and develop genuine problem-solving skills.
  • Emergent Behavior:
    • RL can lead to the emergence of unexpected and valuable behaviors, such as the "thinking" process we see in DeepSeek R1.
  • The Future of LLMs:
    • RL is a crucial area of research and development in the field of LLMs.