The School of LLMs: Post-Training and Reinforcement Learning

Introduction:

We've learned how LLMs are pre-trained on internet data and fine-tuned on human-generated conversations. Now, let's explore the final stage of their education: reinforcement learning. Think of it as sending LLMs to school to refine their skills and make them truly exceptional assistants.

1. The Post-Training Process: A Three-Step Education

• Pre-Training: The Foundation (Reading Textbooks)
  • Just like students start by reading textbooks to gain background knowledge, LLMs are pre-trained on vast amounts of internet text.
  • This stage helps them understand language patterns and build a knowledge base.
  • This stage is like the model learning the general context of the world.
• Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT):
  Learning from Experts (Worked Examples)
  • Students learn from worked examples provided by teachers or textbooks.
  • Similarly, LLMs undergo supervised fine-tuning (SFT) using human-generated conversations, where they learn to imitate expert responses.
  • This is where the model learns how to properly act as an assistant.
• Reinforcement Learning (RL):
  Practice and Refinement (Practice Problems)
  • Students practice solving problems on their own to solidify their understanding.
  • LLMs undergo reinforcement learning to refine their responses and learn to generate optimal outputs through trial and error.
  • This stage is where the model learns to refine its answers, and generate the best possible results.

2. Reinforcement Learning: Learning Through Practice

• The Concept:
  • Reinforcement learning involves training LLMs to generate responses that align with human preferences.
  • Instead of providing expert solutions, we provide feedback on the quality of the LLM's responses.
• The Analogy:
  • Think of it like giving students practice problems with answer keys but without detailed solutions.
  • Students experiment with different approaches and learn from their mistakes.
• The Process:
  • The LLM generates a response to a given prompt.
  • A "reward model" assesses the quality of the response based on human preferences.
  • The LLM adjusts its parameters to generate responses that maximize the reward.
• Key Components:
  • Prompt: The question or instruction given to the LLM.
  • Response: The LLM's generated answer.
  • Reward Model: A system that evaluates the quality of the response.
  • Feedback Loop: The process of adjusting the LLM's parameters based on the reward.

3. Why Reinforcement Learning?

• Beyond Imitation:
  • SFT teaches LLMs to imitate expert responses, but it doesn't necessarily teach them to generate the best possible responses.
  • Reinforcement learning allows LLMs to go beyond imitation and discover optimal strategies.
• Aligning with Human Preferences:
  • Human preferences are often subjective and difficult to define explicitly.
  • Reinforcement learning allows LLMs to learn these preferences through feedback.
• Improving Response Quality:
  • Reinforcement learning helps LLMs generate responses that are more helpful, informative, and engaging.

4. The Teams Involved

• Specialized Teams:
  • Just like a school has different departments, LLM training involves specialized teams for each stage.
  • There are teams for pre-training data, pre-training, SFT, and reinforcement learning.
  • This handoff of models between teams is vital to the training process.

5. The Importance of Practice

• Solidifying Knowledge:
  • Practice problems help students solidify their understanding and develop problem-solving skills.
  • Similarly, reinforcement learning helps LLMs solidify their knowledge and refine their response generation abilities.
• Discovering Optimal Strategies:
  • Practice allows students to experiment with different approaches and discover the most effective strategies.
  • Reinforcement learning enables LLMs to do the same.

---